Do Churches Really Help the Poor? Charity, Texas and the Bible

Chris Mallard spends this episode challenging Christian claims about charity, sacrifice and religious influence in public life. He presses a chat viewer to verify his church’s outreach, walks through the Theocracy Watch maps and a Texas scripture law, and answers viewers on abortion, the Shroud of Turin and more.

Do churches really help the poor?

Chris says many Christians are good people, but argues church culture pulls them away from helping others. He cites survey numbers suggesting larger churches were least likely to help people who asked, while small churches, black churches and mosques were more willing. He tells of a friend, Mike, whose church offered food to homeless people only after a prayer and sermon, and Mike left. Chris asks a viewer to name his church so its outreach can be checked.

Are Christians forcing religion on public schools in Texas?

Chris shows the Theocracy Watch maps covering LGBTQ restrictions, book bans and reproductive bans. He says Texas passed a law requiring children to read scripture aloud unless schools opt out, with lost state funding as the penalty, and that Ten Commandments displays must be visible from every point in the room. He expects it to be killed before taking effect. He tells viewers to search the news themselves and challenges a chat viewer to admit it.

Is the sacrifice of Jesus child sacrifice?

Chris calls it disgusting that a God would ask for sacrifice at all. He describes a deity who demands blood, first from cows and goats and then from humans, and insists the victim be innocent. If Jesus is God’s son, he argues, God sacrificed his own child, which he calls child sacrifice. He also questions why a God who demands worship deserves it, comparing it to a parent demanding glory for a child’s first steps.

Is abortion the same as the slaughter of children in the Bible?

Chris calls the comparison a false equivalency. He points to Bible passages where God commands the slaughter of born, screaming infants pulled from their parents’ arms, and contrasts that with early abortion, which he describes as a puddle of goo. He says society and scientists set limits on how far along abortion is allowed, and he accuses those who push for conception-level bans of wanting to control women.

Is the Shroud of Turin real?

Chris says the Shroud of Turin has been debunked in many ways, including carbon dating and contemporary evidence from the 1300s showing it was a fake. He reasons that if Jesus’s body had been smeared with oils and aloes, the cloth would show that residue and look more like a wet bandage than a clean sheet. He also dismisses Noah’s ark claims in Turkey and calls Ron Wyatt a horrific con man.


Transcript highlights

Selected passages from the live stream, lightly edited for readability. Click a section time to jump to that part of the video.

Show logistics, host break and upcoming lineup

Watch from 4:22

The host opens by saying he is taking a rest day and has built the channel to run on its own, with other hosts stepping in. He says he has been hosting this daily show for over two years and needs a break. He notes that Beard of Empathy and Miss Non-Sequitur will likely run the show the following day, and that he may not need to appear at all if everything goes as planned.

He then walks through the upcoming schedule. Chat and Chill runs on Wednesday nights with Flock Master and Miss Non-Sequitur, and Miss Non-Sequitur’s show follows on Friday nights. He also mentions a weekend edition hosted by Kelly Laughlin, and a Saturday segment called Ask Your Damn Questions, which covers deconstruction and mental health. Beard of Empathy is also planning guest interviews, possibly including John Cohen and someone from Leaving Faith.

He describes plans for a political talk show with Espresso Jack and a co-host, to be streamed on both their channels so that neither host has to skip their regular streaming. He also says he has been reaching out to coffee sponsors and that his theocracy watch project is growing, with a YouTube channel that has nearly a thousand subscribers and a newsletter that viewers can sign up for.

Critique of Christian sacrifice and worship themes

Watch from 15:02

Chris Mallard opens by reflecting on the show’s direction and on his past talks with viewers building their own shows, saying he would prefer an educational element in them. He describes his usual approach of picking a scripture and exposing for Christian viewers how troubling he finds the Bible, adding that he tries not to lump all Christians together as one bloc. He hopes Christians who come on will be open to learning how horrific some biblical passages are, especially ones taught as beautiful.

Mallard then turns to the sacrifice of Jesus, calling it disgusting that a God would command or ask for a sacrifice at all. He describes a deity that demands blood, first cow and goat blood and then human blood, and insists the victim must be innocent. Pressing the point further, he argues that if Jesus is God’s son, then God sacrificed his own child, which he calls child sacrifice. He asks the audience to agree that murdering one’s own child to absolve others of their sins is wrong, and says it is taught as glorious when it is hideous.

Responding to a viewer, Mallard shares his understanding of the legend of Pope Joan, a woman said to have risen to the papacy disguised as a man and later exposed. He notes that a chair was reportedly used to check the testicles of future popes, though he is unsure whether the story is true. He then questions why any God that demands worship would deserve it, comparing it to a parent demanding that a child give the parent all the glory for its first steps or good grades.

Mallard also questions whether God gets stronger from worship and weaker without it, calling that a strange idea and comparing it to images of people worshiping Quetzalcoatl. He cites John chapter 6, where Jesus could do few miracles in his hometown because the people lacked faith. In his reading, Jesus was a conman who could only heal people pretending to be sick, and the passage shows he was not gullible people’s victim. A viewer jokes that they could not find their car keys without Jesus, and Mallard laughs along.

Christian charity, church hypocrisy, and the poor

Watch from 30:03

The host begins by pointing out that many Christians are good people, but says the church culture pulls them away from helping others. He describes how new members are taught to accept brutal Bible stories as good and beautiful, and then start separating themselves from other churches, with Methodists, Episcopalians and Catholics told they are not real Christians. He argues that this divisiveness happens as soon as people walk through the church door.

He says he has seen survey numbers suggesting that the larger Christian churches were the least likely to help people who asked for assistance, while small churches, black churches, and mosques were much more willing to help. He jokes that large churches need more money because the pastor’s daughter needs a Jaguar, and asks whether anyone has ever seen Christians out helping the poor. He suggests an audit of churches to see which ones actually keep food for the needy available, and which ones run outreach where they take supplies out to people.

He then tells the story of a friend named Mike, who attended a church that promised to go out and help the poor. The group went to a park where homeless people gathered and offered food only to those willing to sit through a prayer and a sermon first. Mike was disgusted by this, and he left the church because of it.

The host adds that a businessman in the same church was once broke and poor, and that the church helped him when he needed it. Years later, once he got his life back together and began tithing, the church got its money back. He concludes that this kind of help is not really charity but an investment.

Church charity claims and the fisher of men debate

Watch from 45:04

Chris Mallard pushes a chat viewer who calls himself Fisher of Men to back up his claims that his church does extensive outreach to the poor. Chris argues that good people volunteer at churches, but that the organisations may benefit from their free labour. He says he wants to know the church’s name, its outreach programmes, the value of the preacher’s property, and whether the government subsidises the church’s charitable work. Chris asks the viewer to email the church’s contact details so he can check the claims for himself.

Chris recalls a caller a year earlier who said she was hungry and only wanted basic food and supplies, but was told the church could not help her unless she attended that church. He treats that story as evidence that charity is sometimes conditional on membership. He argues that the viewer’s claims need to be verified rather than simply asserted, and says that his own words are not enough to convince anyone, so the viewer’s words should not be taken at face value either.

The exchange then turns to the viewer’s claim that the pastor earns 60,000 a year, has five children and drives a crappy car. Chris responds that a pastor’s job is to pray for people and to help them, so buying food for people is simply part of the job, and that the viewer has not shown proof of any of it. The viewer says he has bought pizza for a man in a wheelchair and helped people pay their bills, and Chris responds that he will consider these claims only once a verifiable church is named.

Chris then turns to the wider argument about atheism and religion. He says that atheism is simply not believing in a god, and that the real problem is when believers actively force worship on other people. He argues that the claim that all atheists do bad things is as unfair as the claim that all believers do, and he points out that religious texts sometimes explicitly tell followers to do bad things. He also rejects the idea that teaching evolution in schools is forcing atheism on children, calling evolution a scientific theory based on testable, repeatable facts.

Chris also responds to a viewer who claimed to be a former Christian, saying that people who believe in a god are not simply ex-Christians once they stop believing. He criticises the way religious identity is treated as a fixed label, noting that people often say things like “you’re a Christian, not a Muslim” as soon as someone steps through the door. He ends by asking viewers to keep their claims honest and checkable.

Debates on religion, violence, and the Bible

Watch from 1:00:03

Chris Mallard argues that religious groups have a long history of violence against one another, pointing to early conflicts among colonists in the United States. He claims the Bible does not teach that a man who does not work should not eat, and he points to Jesus feeding five thousand people as a counterexample. He says a viewer’s ignorance of their own religious text is staggering, and that Jesus giving away food directly contradicts the claim.

He describes God as a totalitarian system rather than a fascist one, saying there is no vote in heaven and that God rules with generals, commanders, and angels beneath him. He also argues that democracy has nothing to do with Jesus or worshiping him, since believers have no real choice in the matter.

On Richard Dawkins, Mallard says atheists do not treat him as a pope or as a source of doctrine, and that many atheists are critical of him, particularly for his views on transgender people. He also raises the question of whether cultural Christians like Dawkins take the baggage of Christian beliefs about women’s authority over men with them.

Turning to the Shroud of Turin, Mallard says the shroud has been debunked in many ways, including carbon dating and contemporary evidence from the 1300s showing it was a fake. He reasons that if Jesus’s body had been smeared with oils and aloes, the shroud would show that residue, and it would look more like a wet bandage than a clean cloth. He also dismisses claims about Noah’s ark in Turkey, saying the evidence has repeatedly shown them to be untrue, and he calls Ron Wyatt a horrific con man.

Mallard then explains how the show’s AI fact-checking tool works. He says it transcribes the show, checks his claims, and posts corrections to the Discord server. He gives an example from Exodus 22, which he says calls for the sacrifice of children, arguing that the Ten Commandments are not the whole of the law and that the text goes on well past the first ten. He says the AI tool sometimes gets things wrong, so he has another instance check it as well.

Christian influence, Texas laws, and evidence debates

Watch from 1:15:44

We all believe in something. Not all of it is God, and it really doesn’t matter to me. I don’t think it matters. My own opinion is that I really don’t care what you believe, and I don’t have time to care. I want to go do my own stuff. I want to do theater, I want to do writing, I want to play video games, and I wanted to sit around masturbating all the time. I don’t want to be sitting here doing this.

But you hurt people. Not you specifically, Gretsett, I don’t know who you are or what you are, but Christians right here in our country hurt people. They oppress people. They put things on people that they shouldn’t, and they stick their business into other people’s lives. I’ve got the Theocracy Watch map, and I’m going to bring it up on the screen so you can see where religious people are forcing their business on others.

Look at the LGBTQ restrictions map. That’s where your religious beliefs are being forced on gay people and trans people, right here in these states. You can click on one of these states and scroll down, and it will tell you what’s going on there. Look at Texas, where they’re forcing their bullshit on homosexuals, trans people, and people in general. They just can’t mind their own fucking business, can they?

Next is the books and exemptions map. This is where your people are forcing their book bans and stuff like that into public schools, going around telling other people what their children can and can’t read. That’s you, right there. Your people are doing that. Then there’s the reproductive bans map. That’s the abortion issue, and I should have these memorized because I rebuilt this this morning. It’s up to date too, and this is about abortion bans and controlling women in their bodies. This is what your people are doing.

This is why I don’t talk about Islam, because Christians are doing this right here in our country right now. This is Christians forcing their bullshit on everybody else. So I’m not just here because I hate your God. I’m not just here because I want to sin, although that is part of it, to be honest. But what is sin, my friends? Sin is nothing but a word for the things you do to other people.

So why do we do what we do? Because I hate your God? No, because I’m tired of your bullshit getting forced on me, on my children, and on my women. I’ve got a wife and a daughter of breeding age, so that’s kind of the point. Of course, I’m one of those people who doesn’t need it to hurt me personally before I’m against it. Unlike most conservatives, it would appear.

Then there’s the Ten Commandments in classrooms. It started with just the Ten Commandments in classrooms, but now Texas has literally passed a law requiring children to read scripture out loud in school. All children in public schools must do it unless the school opts out, and if they opt out they lose state funding. That doesn’t go into effect yet, and by the time it does it’ll almost certainly be killed, but they tried, and they would have if they could have. The law even says the Ten Commandments must be large enough to be seen from every point in the room. That’s forcing your bullshit on our kids. How is it not?

Let me pull up the article. Here it is, the Texas State Board of Education voting to make Bible passages required reading. So your people are literally trying to force our children to read scripture in school, or the school loses the money. That’s not forcing things on them? You can search for it yourself. I just did, and it only took a moment to find articles. I’m going to post this one, just one of the few at the top, so you can see I’m not making this shit up. Christians are really forcing your bullshit on other people here in the United States.

Now, somebody in the chat said “Fishers of men,” Matthew, and that’s not an answer. Are you going to admit that some of your Christian friends are trying to force their religion on children in public schools? Can you admit that or not? This has been an ongoing test of honesty with this person and these people, and this is a perfect example. Can you say, “Yeah, some of my Christian brethren are forcing our religion on your children in schools”? I’ve shown you one of the web pages, and you can go look for yourself. I’m just waiting for your response.

God’s favorite said that you can’t guarantee people will find the same thing when they Google it. That’s absolutely true, and that’s why I want them to Google it. It was something that happened in state law. It’s not me, and it’s not Google. Go look for that yourself. If it’s true, you’ll find it. You can’t pretend the ABC News article is unreliable just because you don’t like it. Go look for yourself.

This is for those of you who wonder why I don’t debate these people. Here’s why. A viewer wrote “distortions of truth, lied to cover up your atheism,” and I just went through the web page. Did you go look for yourself? Did you find out that Texas is trying to force non-Christian children in public schools to read scripture daily? Can you admit that? No distortion of truth there. Yes, you do it all the time, lying to cover up your Christianity.

I’m not a good debater, and I don’t think that’s because I’m wrong. There’s a process to debating. A call-in show is a call-in show, but a real debate has rules, and I just don’t have the patience for it. I’ve done the call-in thing. Go watch the first couple of months of this year, when we took calls every day. There was one with Kelly Laughlin that just broke me. I was already over it, and this caller had what he called contemporary evidence of Jesus.

Contemporary means it was written while Jesus was alive, by somebody who knew Jesus. That’s what it means. Then he went on about Tacitus, and I said no, Tacitus doesn’t count, because Tacitus wasn’t even born when

Part 7

Watch from 1:30:03

Oh, I see you’re one of those Gretsett. Let’s see user history To unalive babies in the womb you have to be careful. It’s not the same It’s not the same that we’ve got Christians coming in here and I can show you examples in the Bible where God commands the slaughter Of babies infants, but these are born crying screaming infants ripped unwillingly from their parents arms Who then were also slaughtered? You’re trying to compare that to an abortion in which a puddle of goo is made to not be a baby later That’s what you’re trying to compare it to and it’s not even the same in our science in our in our Society, it’s not right

We have a limit as to how far along a baby can be before We allow that to happen because for those very reasons not free I mean to because it’s a baby and we scientists and people determine that not me not you But you want to go to conception because you want to control women to make sure women don’t get to have fun without having some repercussions They want to have sex without have repercussions because they might enjoy it and have it without you So trying to compare abortion to murdering alive screaming children is a false equivalency Isn’t it and You make it sound I mean the what they didn’t Bible was forced that they

went and slaughtered those children That’s I mean, I don’t I don’t even see why you guys try to compare it, but but very often Theists come in here and try to do that. You try to compare abortion to what your God commanded the slaughter of babies and children Hmm Jinxie for you Jinxie you says since you mentioned trans I didn’t know that they were I hadn’t really put those two together Thank you, my friend. I don’t really Says take a look into pastor Alvin Christian the operator of a food bank that refused donations from any source He deemed as trans supported Right. I mean, it’s all about hate. I feel like it’s all about hate

They got to find somebody what percentage of people out there are trans It’s such a small percentage of people that they want to hate against and I mean They They’re just about the hurt it just Jesus himself said he acknowledged intersex people Jesus did Jesus did Jesus himself in his own words acknowledged intersex people You’ve heard that thing about being a eunuch and if if you’re strong in the in your religion and in your faith And you can take on that You should take on that. He says there are eunuchs who are born and Other men make them eunuchs like a king who take makes his guards eunuchs so they can’t impregnate the Queen that

sort of thing there are men out there who Take that solemn oath of their own for their Lord and they remove that they become eunuchs as a as a an oath to the Lord and some Men are born eunuchs naturally. He says it right there. Some people are born eunuchs That’s intersex and that’s Jesus acknowledging intersex people and yet you hate them That’s kind of not even the same though. Really just depends that that man that does get more complicated as far as intersex and gender and See what I mean. I’m not qualified for that I don’t really see why you guys should be mason making that a line in the sand to hurt other

people about Why not help them and another thing is Christians you’re good Christian. You want to help people who are in need and who are hurting you think these people are sick You think they’re in need and hurting and you’re gonna be ugly and hurt them more Isn’t that weird rather than try to find another way? Your goal is to hurt them more. Oh Yeah, pull knowledge hub God telling people to set apart their firstborn of consecration Holiness is not the same as him saying to kill that same child I’ve read that for you over and over again, dude I’ve shown you where there’s a redemption clause and when there’s not a redemption clause and

Host plans changes and shares personal stories

Watch from 1:45:02

I’ve been burnt out really, and I’m trying to make the show fun for me again. I’m almost certainly going to take a break of about a week, whether that means playing replays or getting the other hosts to step in. When I come back I want it to be more educational and more fun. I don’t know yet how I’m going to do that, but I’m trying by giving you guys the opportunity to vote on the commercials, and I can do Atheist bingo if you want.

The reason we don’t run bingo is that I’m usually alone running the show, and I don’t have the bandwidth to keep up with it and do everything else. My mods could probably keep up with it if they’re willing to try, and I might run it right now. We don’t have any mods in the room though. You’d have to be in our special mod room, which I built.

I don’t really understand the whole idea that you should be forced to donate an organ or blood to save a child’s life, and there are a lot of false equivalencies that go around here. Wait a second, you want to force people to have babies against their will, but you’re not willing to adopt? I’m


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *