This episode looks at Christian nationalism and whether it fits the morality of the Bible it claims to follow. Chris and his guests define the movement, describe the networks behind it, and talk about practical local ways to push back. The conversation also detours into faith healing and miracle claims.
What is Christian nationalism, and how is it different from a Christian in politics?
The guest describes Christian nationalism as an individual, group or ideology that wants a very particular, authoritarian version of Christian-themed behaviors and laws implemented in the United States government. He says this is different from a Christian who follows Jesus and is engaged in politics. According to the guest, Christian nationalists are open that they do not care about violating the Constitution to get what they want. He adds that most people who call themselves Christian would not agree with it, but it is vocal, active and well funded right now.
Does Christian nationalism contradict Christian morality?
Chris says Christian nationalism seems to go the opposite way of Christian morality. He notes he is not a scholar, but that people who study the subject have said the same, and he argues the message across the biblical books does not match the movement. The discussion points to a network that includes Project 2025, the Heritage Foundation and Focus on the Family. Chris also describes an annual gathering of about 100 white nationalists, who he says are Christian nationalists too, in a Tennessee state park, advocating the killing of immigrants, Black people and Jewish people.
How can ordinary people push back against Christian nationalism?
The hosts urge listeners to get involved locally instead of voting once and checking out. They suggest joining volunteer committees, attending monthly or quarterly meetings, supporting local businesses over big chains, and showing up at places like fire departments. Chris notes that many Tennessee local races were uncontested, almost always with Republicans unopposed, and mentions a nonprofit recruiting candidates for them. They point out the recent election does not take effect until January, so representatives must be held accountable. Chris adds that helping others can recharge you even when you are tired and broke.
Can faith in Jesus actually heal people?
Georgie argues that everything is about focus and allowance, that we are all gods, and that Jesus saying your faith has healed you means people heal themselves. Chris asks whether that is metaphorical or literal, and whether faith in Jesus can heal a cut finger. He says that if someone makes supernatural claims, he needs to see them. Chris also asks why gravity and baking soda with vinegar work the same everywhere, while faith healing seems to happen in the Congo but not in Tennessee.
Transcript highlights
Selected passages from the live stream, lightly edited for readability. Click a section time to jump to that part of the video.
Defining Christian Nationalism and Its Clash With Morality
Chris: It seems to me that Christian nationalism goes the opposite of Christian morality. Tell me if I’m wrong, but I’m pretty sure I’m not. I’m not a scholar on these subjects, but a good couple of people who do study them have said the same thing. The message taught throughout the broad canon of what is considered the Bible, or the biblical books in general, does not adhere to what Christian nationalism is.
Guest: I think the best way to understand Christian nationalism is when an individual, a group, or an ideology specifically wants a very particular, authoritarian version of Christian-themed behaviors and laws implemented in the United States government. It’s not just somebody who believes, as a Christian and as someone who follows Jesus Christ’s teachings, whatever those are for them, that our laws should broadly reflect those things. That is not a Christian nationalist. That is just a Christian who is engaged in politics.
Christian nationalism is a specific ideology about taking over the United States government, and doing so in a way that violates the current laws of the government. They are open about this. They are clear that they don’t care if they have to violate the Constitution as long as they get what they want. It is a very specific view of Christianity, one that they believe the Bible wants them to hold.
It is not something the majority of people who take the label of Christian would agree with. But it is a very vocal, very active, and very well-funded version of Christianity right now. That is one reason we are seeing it the way we are today, and it is worth understanding how it differs from the faith most Christians actually practice.
Chris: Yeah, and feel free to interrupt me at any point. I’m going to ramble on this subject, because it’s one I care about. Anybody in chat, go ahead and ramble too. As long as they’re adhering to what we’re discussing, I’ll just yell shut up at them a couple of times.
Christian Nationalist Networks and Open Hatred
This started a long time ago, when a bunch of people got together and said, what if we do this? That is where we end up getting things like Project 2025, that massive document, the Heritage Foundation, and Focus on the Family. There are all these different groups that make up this massive network. So yes, it is a really terrifying thing.
Does that make it harder to fight back, because you can hit one group but there are still 18 others going strong? Yes and no. It is not one single thing doing it. It is a whole network of organizations that hold it all together.
Do you prefer that they never say the terrible things they think, so you never have to see it? Or is it better that they are really open about the fact that they hate groups of people and want to see those people exterminated? Because then it is really clear. Oh yeah, those guys.
Every year in my state of Tennessee, there is a white nationalist group that comes in. They are Christian nationalists as well, and it is about 100 strong. These individuals rent out a park for a weekend and have this big convention where they are literally advocating for killing various groups of people. We are talking about immigrants, Black people, and Jewish people. Because it is a state park, they have to let them do it. It is the law. But it is also gross and terrifying to think that there is a group that just comes together every year in my state.
It is a frustrating thing, man. It is a frustrating thing.
I remember back in the 80s, because I am that old unfortunately, when these guys weren’t really out in the open. You didn’t know who they were. I lived out in the cornfields in Illinois back then, and there was a small town that was basically all of them. They were members of an organization that uses three letters, all the same. I had no idea that was happening in this little town just five miles down the road.
So it is hard for me to say whether it is better then or better now. At least back then they weren’t being so active and going out and doing things in the open the way they are today. Now they just feel safe being bigots. Do you prefer the hatred to be open like that,
Heaven, Healing, and Testing Supernatural Claims
Chris asked Georgie whether the idea was that you don’t have to go to heaven because heaven is inside you. Georgie said he had heard that a lot, and pointed to a passage where the people around Jesus are going to accuse him of something, and he asks, “Is it not written that you are gods?” Chris then turned to John 3:16: “For God so loved the world that he gave his only begotten Son, that whoever believes in him has eternal life, shall not perish.” He explained that this can very reasonably be understood to mean that everyone who accepts Jesus Christ as the way, the truth, and the light actually has eternal life, and everyone who doesn’t does not.
Chris said he thought both of them could reasonably reach either conclusion from a handful of different passages. He added that this isn’t really a hinge point for the belief system or for most of the people in it. He said many of his pastor friends would call it a third tier issue. “Is Matthew actually written before Mark, or is Mark written before Matthew? That’s not a super important thing. Whether or not Jesus is the Son of God, whether or not Jesus resurrected from the dead, those are the most important things.” He also said he doesn’t mind conceding a point, and that Georgie’s answer was a good one.
Georgie then explained his view that everything is about focus and allowance, with more emphasis on allowance. He described how he started making YouTube videos of the game Counter Strike, and how after a couple of years, shorts and content arose, and now he gets a good number of views automatically through the algorithm. Chris asked if he was saying that he didn’t need Jesus to do that, and that the ability was already within him. Georgie agreed: “That basically we are all gods and you can do those things.” Chris asked whether Georgie had been able to do those things himself by focusing, and Georgie said yes.
Georgie said that the more we focus, the better we get at a thing, and the better we make that thing happen. He pointed to the line where Jesus says it is your faith that has healed you, and said that the person has to heal themselves in a sense. Chris said that sounds like it’s on the same page, but when you start talking about healing others, that seems to him like a supernatural attribute. “If you’re going to make supernatural claims, how do we get there? Like Jesus healing the blind, for example.”
Chris used snow to make his point. He said you could describe snow as a beautiful white comforter that blankets the ground and hugs it as tightly as a mother who loves her child. “But it’s snow. It’s ice crystals that have fallen from the sky.” So when you say your faith in Jesus is what heals you, Chris asked, does that actually translate to a stubbed toe or a cut finger? “If not, then it doesn’t really matter to me in all honesty. But if it does, then I need to see that.” He asked whether this is metaphorical or literal, and whether you can actually heal people.
Chris asked Georgie to be clear about this, and asked whether he had ever cut his finger, maybe while chopping vegetables. Chris said he had nicked himself recently while tumbling rocks. Then he asked, “Can that be healed through faith in Jesus Christ, Georgie? Next time I accidentally cut my finger while slicing up tomatoes, will my faith in Jesus Christ
Part 4
Because wherever I go, if I fly to Bulgaria right now and you and I look at a big rock and we take that rock and we push it off of a hill, it’s going to roll down that hill. It doesn’t matter whether it’s our hometown, whether it’s not, it doesn’t matter. Wherever we put baking soda and vinegar together on this planet, it will always do the same thing. Why is this not the case when it comes to these miracle things, man? Why is it that, yeah, Jesus can’t do miracles in his hometown? Like, I don’t know, God just didn’t work in Nazareth for some reason. It doesn’t make sense, man. Math works everywhere. It’s always
the same. Gravity is always the same. Why isn’t this true when it comes to faith healing or ghosts or any of these other things? Yeah, and fine. air getting through the surgery. We got to stop here. Why do you think that’s a miracle? And if that’s the explanation, fine. We’ll go with that. But most people, at least from my understanding, especially coming from a Christian or an Abrahamic faith background, like, you don’t really believe in those types of things. So, like, I don’t know, why is this the case, Georgie? What is it about these different places that really seem to affect, you know? There’s all this faith healing going on in, like, the Congo right
now. But, like, why isn’t it happening in Tennessee? well in your country you have other miracles like people surviving that you know Yeah, but, like, surviving, you know, like, you’re talking about, like, spontaneous remission and stuff from, like, somebody… yes yes that also but I’m talking about the medical procedures surgery no the surviving part is a miracle well it’s the stage we’re in right now Wait, I’m sorry. Are you saying, are you… Okay, so you’re saying, like, the surgery is a miracle. Okay, okay. Like, there was a complication. Yeah, yeah, okay, okay, yeah, yeah, yeah. Yeah, yeah, I get you, I get you. And, yeah, I mean, yeah. Isn’t that just something people do? You
know, I mean, so many people are able to survive surgeries. I’ve survived three surgeries myself. You know, I don’t consider any of those a miracle. I just consider that really good medicine, right? Why do you think that’s a miracle? That’s what I’m Right, right. wondering. I’m not sure what you mean by allowance. Not trying to make something happen. I viewed it like that I view it like that what can I say it’s like I like I said previously it’s all about focus and allowance and it’s the middle way not trying to make something happen allowing it Yeah, I’m not 100 % positive. I mean, it… So like wanting something to happen with all your being
and then just totally giving it up, and that’s how you get it. Interesting. Do you know who D .T. Suzuki was? He was a yes you already have it yes no I’m sorry yeah to some extent I agree with you yeah I agree but so I don’t know how to respond to that precisely So, it’s that… Yeah, yeah. That name sounds… Zen Buddhist. He actually was the one who brought Zen Buddhism to the United States. So he was kind of a famous guy back in the 1950s, 60s. And he said something that like has followed me really well through a lot of my life. And he talked about the path to enlightenment. And he said,
when you first start out on the path to enlightenment, mountains are mountains and rivers are rivers. And then when you get along your path, you realize that mountains are no longer mountains and rivers are no longer rivers. And then when you become enlightened, you realize that, yeah, mountains are mountains and rivers are rivers. And I feel like the way you’re talking, Georgie, that you’re at that point where the mountains are not mountains and the rivers are not rivers. Yeah. So I just think maybe you need to walk that path a little more and, you know, like I used to hear a lot of what you say, things like the way I knew what you were
Part 5
And Tennessee is one of the least voting states out there. So we absolutely had the ability to win in in certain districts that, you know, in in past elections went 10, 15, 20 points, you know, towards Trump or the GOP in general, like they flipped. They not just that they not just that they moved a couple of percentage points to the left, but they they literally elected for the first time, you know, candidates that are not from the Republican Party. That’s phenomenal. Mississippi literally has. And this is this is insane. There are so many insane things that happen this election. Mississippi has the first ever elected black representative from their state. Right. For for for
Senate, because while they have had black senators in the past, they were technically put there by the legislature, which was a law that that was changed during reconstruction time. And so then, like, a hundred some odd years went by and Mississippi was just like, nah, nah, fuck it. Now we don’t need we don’t need a black senator. That’s crazy. Yes, right. We have the first we have the first black woman that is a governor of a state anywhere. yeah, yeah, right, right. You know what? One of the things that, you know, I’m an old man, That’s amazing. We have the first Native American woman that’s a governor of a state. There’s so many there. There
are so many so many different trans non binary folks that were elected in various races. I I am very, very pleased in it, you know, in a lot of ways when it comes to this most recent election. And I think, yes, there there was a huge repudiation of a lot of what the Christian Nationalists want. I also will say, though, you know, it is worth remembering that this the last couple of years we have had a pretty out of the norm economic cycle, like what has been going on over the last couple of years in the United States has been a little out of step with the rest of the world in a couple of
different ways. You know, for anybody that that is a super big nerd and loves to follow international politics and stuff, you probably noticed that a couple of other countries had elections as well over the last handful of months, some before us in the U .S., some some, you know, are coming up here shortly. But a lot of times those elections are kind of mirror each other. Right there. When you see a big left wing swing in the Australian parliament, you you tend to see you tend to see that happening in Latin America, in Canada, here in the U .S. You know, it just we do this kind of back and forth shift a lot. Right
now, when it comes to our economic stability, for sure, we have taken a different turn than the rest of, you know, our countries, our like OECD, you know, countries and shit. And a big part of that has been because of the policies of Trump and and these Christian nationalists. And like, that’s something that people are starting to recognize is that these parties just they do just ultimately make people’s lives worse. These these policies are just bad for everybody. They and and not just bad in the sense of like, oh, you know, the the beautiful secularism that our country is founded on the ideals and principles are being eroded. No, it’s literally like your your dollar
is worth less. Like there there are empty shelves at the grocery store because of these policies. So it is it is, you know, six to one half dozen of the other, I guess. There’s part of me that’s really excited and like, yay, maybe we’re paying attention. And then there’s part of me that’s just like, you know, I don’t know. People are just probably tired of paying so much for gas. so I’ve been around a while. And one of the things that I see happening today that really gives me a lot of hope. And unfortunately, I see a little bit on the other side too, is that there’s so many, so many younger people getting involved
Local Engagement Against Christian Nationalism
Part of the recent shift in Tennessee came from gerrymandering that the GOP did right before the election. They cut things up in a way that was meant to make it harder, but they put enough people together in these places who hadn’t been listened to, people nobody had ever talked to before. And next thing you know, the only person showing up at your door is the Democratic candidate. Does this local, at-home stuff matter to you and your neighbors? We don’t have to get super deep and ideological about it. Guys, we should have roads that don’t have massive holes in them. That’s not crazy, and that’s not political. You shouldn’t have to drive two hours to go to a hospital. If one group in politics says they don’t really care whether kids have hospitals, and another group says they do, you vote for the second group. It’s that simple.
The party that’s for veterans, for children, and for small business is absolutely right now the number one enemy of every one of those groups. You’ve got somebody like Linda McMahon running the small business department for this country. She’s the co-owner of the massive multi-million dollar international corporation, the WWE. I’m sure she really has a lot of insight to help the local mom and pop shop. There are probably volunteer committees in your town that are dying for people, and it’s nonsense.
We have to remember that the election that just happened doesn’t actually take effect until January. For the next month and a half, we have to come back to this and start holding our representatives accountable. We can’t just vote once and then check out for three or four years. We have to get involved in our local issues, in meetings and groups. You need to be out there on your days off doing what you can. I’m talking to myself too. In my small town there’s a historical museum, and the committee that runs its funding and programs is begging people to sit on it. There’s all kinds of stuff you can do in your community, and it gives you the experience to move on to bigger things. Maybe you start realizing what the city council does and you want to run for a city council seat. It all starts somewhere. Everything’s local.
One tactic the religious right and the Christian nationalists are using in this country is going after museums and scientific institutions. They’re going after the basic framework structures that have existed in our country for forever, and they want to take them away and prevent us from ever talking about history they don’t like. The things you need to stand up for right now aren’t always the flashiest or the most exciting. Maybe what you need to do is show up at your local fire department’s annual cookout just to talk to the people there, because there are groups infiltrating fire departments and turning them into white nationalist gangs. Go support a local business, a restaurant, a rock shop, or a clothing store, because you’re much more likely to affect their stances on things than you are at Wal-Mart or CVS. Those companies will give ten million dollars to every candidate, because they write that off every year and whoever wins, they owe them. So go where your dollar matters more. Participate in the places where you have more of a say. If only three people show up to this monthly or quarterly meeting, that’s fantastic, because when you start showing up, you are twenty-five percent of that decision-making. Bring your friends and just participate.
I know it’s hard. I’m tired, I’m broke, and I never have enough time in the day. But there are studies that seem to indicate that when you’re feeling like that, the best thing you can do is start helping others. Even if you have hardly anything to give, the tiniest amount helps recharge our batteries. Things don’t change on their own. I was waiting for something else to change my own views out of religious thinking, and it didn’t happen. I had to change on my own. You’ve got to make a change.
Many local races in Tennessee were uncontested, and it was almost always Republicans running unopposed. Most people don’t realize there is only one person to vote for in those elections. There is a nonprofit tracking uncontested elections across the country and trying to recruit candidates to run in them. I usually write in people. I actually ran for mayor once, before I really had my life together. It’s weird that this is where we’ve gotten as a voting populace. Even the framers of the Constitution thought more and more of us would pay attention as the years went on, and for whatever reason, we just haven’t. I know it sounds crazy after all these terrible things, but I am optimistic about the next handful of years in this country.
Left wing policy, polling, and mandatory voting
I was not a good candidate, but I did alright. Out of four candidates, I came in fourth, so at least I finished. My feeling very much is that our country is very hungry for a good couple of left wing ideologies and policies to go into place. Things that are typically considered left wing economically, like universal health care or doing away with the electoral college, or changing dramatically how we do policing, are not fringe talking points anymore. They are very much in the mainstream, because of how bad it has gotten in so many ways. We are still doing way better than a lot of other places around the world, and we have so much privilege in this country, but many people are for the first time having to ask themselves how they are going to pay for things.
It shouldn’t be a crazy thing to bury your grandfather without it bankrupting the whole family, but it does now. A baby with a cough that goes on for too long, you go to the doctor, and next thing you know you’re $20,000 in debt. That just doesn’t make sense. We have gotten to a place where more and more people recognize that the world can’t continue in that fashion. You can’t have counties that don’t have hospitals or school districts that aren’t properly funded. That’s a big thing in rural America. I’m going to tell everybody right now, all these people who live in the cities don’t realize how bad it is. If I need to see a specialist, it’s sometimes a three month wait, and I have to drive an hour and a half to see them. That’s just the reality in rural America.
There’s a ton of different reasons why that’s the case. It’s not one simple, easy thing we could just do, but it does require a government that is purposefully thinking about these types of issues. That is the
Government, Taxation and the Bill Cooper Argument
Matthew argued that the foundation of government is evil because it stems from forcing someone to give somebody else money under the threat of going to jail. When pressed on how that is not true, he said, “It’s the basis of it, though. It’s the foundation.” The host responded that government is not taxation, and that the discussion could go back as far as needed. “What is the definition of a government in the most basic political theory sense that has been talked about for thousands of years? Government is an organization of individuals that are focused on the citizens that make up the population. Does that make sense?”
The host then explained that government does not even have to collect taxes at all. “You can have a system like the one Kropotkin came up with, that’s fine. This is literally thousands of years old, dude. If you’re not up to that level, don’t come in here pretending.” He gave two historical examples: “There was a system where every ten people elect one person to go on to the next ten people. That was how they ran Barcelona during the Spanish civil war. It was also how they set up a temporary government in Ukraine after World War I, until the Bolsheviks knocked them off. There was no taxation in either one of those.”
The host was clear that the point was not a gotcha. “If you just admit that you’re wrong, we can move on and say, hey, in modern times, the only way that in practice a government works is by collecting revenue in some form or fashion. But taxation doesn’t have to be that way. You’re trying to get to a more interesting point, Matthew.” He added, “What’s the point of having a conversation if you’re not going to be honest?”
When Matthew continued to say that the system requires people to pay, the host brought up a counterexample. “Do you know who Bill Cooper is? Didn’t William Cooper get killed because he didn’t pay taxes?” The host responded that if Matthew was going to bring up Bill Cooper, he had basically just lost the argument. “He was killed. He didn’t start, the authorities didn’t start that gunfight. He did. If you don’t know about that, you need to go and learn more about what happened with Bill Cooper, and from a not pro Cooper website, because there’s a lot more of the story that you don’t seem to understand.”
The host also commented on Matthew’s manner in the conversation. “I think if you showed up to this conversation and were able to be a little bit more humble and moderate your statements, you’d be more effective. I don’t think you have these really intense, hard stances, but you’ve been trained because of the things that you’ve looked at in your life, many of which I imagine are also very incorrect. I just think you’d be more effective if you were more honest with yourself and others.” He said the reason it was so frustrating was that Matthew had clearly not been ready for the conversation he

Leave a Reply