This episode asks whether the God of the Bible behaves like a deadbeat father. Greg James and the hosts draw on their own childhoods, stories such as Abraham, Job and Jephthah, and the doctrine of the Trinity to question the idea of a loving heavenly Father. They also discuss how that image can shape real families.
Why do atheists call God a deadbeat father?
Greg explains that his own father left when he was about seven or eight, and he used him as an anti-hero, asking what his dad would do and then doing the opposite. He points out that God is called Father throughout both testaments, starting with the first words of the Lord’s Prayer, and says he found roughly 238 New Testament references. Yet the Bible shows God killing children, and Greg says that even if God were real he would not worship him.
What do Abraham and Job show about God as a father?
Greg rejects the claim that Abraham showed faith and obedience, arguing that the request to sacrifice a son is the real problem. Another host retells Job as a wager between God and Satan, in which Satan is allowed to kill Job’s children and destroy his life. God then gives Job a new family as if that made up for the loss. The host calls this a tone deaf understanding of fatherhood and says he could never ask his own son to do such a thing.
Which Old Testament punishments clash with the idea of a loving Father?
The host cites the killing of the firstborn of Egypt and the Amalekites, including infants and young boys, while the young girls were kept. He also recalls Jephthah, who vowed to sacrifice whatever first came out of his house, and God did not stop the sacrifice as he did with Abraham. He calls this a pattern rather than isolated cases. He adds that as a teenager he was persuaded by Mark Twain’s argument that God was a sadist for planting the tree of knowledge and then punishing Adam and Eve.
Is the Trinity actually in the Bible?
The host argues that the Trinity is a comforting doctrine that falls apart under scrutiny. People do not refer to themselves in the third person, he says, so it is odd for God to speak as Father and Son. He compares it to a title like Officer Greg. He concludes the Trinity is not a biblical concept but evolved in the Catholic Church over centuries, with Tertullian likely the first to discuss it around the third century, and later groups followed the Catholic example.
How does the image of God as a harsh father affect children?
The hosts discuss the idea of spare the rod and spoil the child, and how children can be taught that they made their father hit them. They say men raised in church may believe they can be physically abusive and loving at once. Greg shares that he has lived with CPTSD and was once a homeless alcoholic and drug addict, but got control in his mid 30s and raised his kids differently. The hosts note a cycle of violence in highly religious households, where the father stands in for God.
Transcript highlights
Selected passages from the live stream, lightly edited for readability. Click a section time to jump to that part of the video.
Guest introduction and atheist podcast overview
The segment opened with a welcome to the show, and the host introduced his guest as the executive producer of the Atheist Community of Austin. The guest explained that the group produces a series of YouTube podcasts, the best known of which is The Atheist Experience. He also mentioned other shows the group runs, including Truth Wanted. He said it was an unfamiliar experience to be on the other side of the camera, having usually been the one running the productions.
Part 2
GREG ON GOD AS A DEADBEAT FATHER
Greg explained why he chose this topic: “It’s become one of my pet topics recently, and it’s the one I feel maybe best equipped to explain, defend, or talk about. I have experience as a dad and now as a granddad, which are two fundamentally different roles, but I wouldn’t call myself an expert in it, even though I have some fully functional children, I believe.”
He traced his interest back to his own childhood. “I grew up not in the best family situation. My dad left when I was about seven or eight years old. I always suspected, although I wasn’t able to confirm it because I was adopted, that he didn’t see me as his own natural child. He was just not taking full responsibility, which I think is absolutely wrong.”
Greg said that experience shaped how he read the Bible. “I grew up using him as my anti-hero. A lot of people ask, what would Jesus do in this situation? I would ask, what would my dad do? Then I’d do the polar opposite, and it generally wound up being the right thing to do.”
On the idea of God as Father, Greg pointed to how often it appears. “The concept of God as the father of humanity is peppered throughout the entire Bible, Old Testament and New. The most popular prayer, Our Father who art in heaven, has it within the first two words. But if you start from that basis and then look at what this God does in the Bible, you see horrific examples of killing children. Hell, he killed his own child just so he could get around the rules he set up in the first place.”
He then turned to the story of Abraham. “I was always on the other side of that argument. I’ve heard it said that Abraham was showing faith and obedience when God told him to take his son up the mountain and sacrifice him. I’d say, fuck you, dude. You’re not getting that. The fact that you asked me to do that is the problem. As a father, with my meager, mortal cognitive skills, I can look at that and say no, that’s not what a father should be doing.”
Greg added a personal conclusion. “Even if God happens to be real, I still wouldn’t worship that asshole because I’m a better person than he is. If he sends me to hell, he will always know for eternity that I was a better person than him and he still sent me.”
Another host shared a similar experience. “I had a not great childhood myself, and an abusive father was normal to me. When I was growing up and learning all these Bible stories, they just seemed like the normal things fathers did. It wasn’t until I became a father myself that I realized the best thing I could do was the opposite of what my stepfather taught me. If we use the fatherly lessons of the Bible that way, we might be much better parents.”
Greg then commented on the chat. “It floors me that a lot of religious people will either accept the image of God as a father and not question anything in the Bible, or there are other Christians who absolutely say, no, God is not your father, God is God. Each one calls themselves by the same label but has a different interpretation, and they tailor it to their preconceived notions. The Bible is, if nothing else, a wonderful book for finding a supporting argument for whatever you believe across the spectrum.”
He also responded to a chat comment. “I’ve got to say something to Matthew Danovic. Was it okay for millions of Christians to kill each other during the Thirty Years War? If you’re going to make that kind of argument, let’s go the whole route and use all of history.”
On preparing for the show, Greg described the document he put together. “We’ve been going with a prompt for the hosts, a reference they can go to exactly. For this topic, I was pleasantly surprised at the vast number of things either calling God Father or referring to Him that way in both testaments. For the New Testament, I have roughly 238 references. There’s always the argument that the Old Testament was replaced by the New Covenant, so I wanted to cover that too.”
Finally, the hosts turned to super chats. One suggested a challenge: “For each super chat, we could alternate telling one of our most embarrassing father stories.” The other agreed and said, “I’ve got endless amounts of embarrassments that I’ve experienced as a dad, so I’ll tell that story.”
Divine Fatherhood, Job, and Abraham
Viewers raise the question of why God is always described as male, and the host suggests that the Bible’s authors made their central figure a more manly man. He compares this to Greek gods, who made mistakes, felt jealousy and anger, and were therefore more believable as characters. He argues that the Christian God is portrayed as all powerful and yet still demands worship at every chance.
The host also questions how a single being could know nine trillion people intimately, counting every hair on their heads and knowing what they will eat for breakfast. He suggests this idea works only because each believer has invented a God in their own head. He adds that the people he finds most egotistical are those who believe a deity that created trillions of galaxies picked this one small dot in one small solar system as the place where it matters most.
Asked for an example of God as a bad father, the host points to the story of Job and to Abraham’s near sacrifice of Isaac. He says he could never imagine asking his son to kill one of his own children, calling it one of the cruelest things he could think of. He then retells the Job story as a wager between God and Satan, in which God allows Satan to kill Job’s children and destroy his life, then rewards him with a new family as if that could make up for the loss. He says this shows a tone deaf understanding of what it means to be a father.
Reflecting on his own family, the host describes his son’s trauma after several quick deaths in the maternal family and says he would never stop standing by him. He then talks about his son-in-law, whom he refuses to call an in-law because he sees him simply as his son. He describes how the young man grew up in a religious household, was overshadowed as a middle child, and was gradually discounted by the family. The host says he has worked to grow closer to him, and that he is proud his daughter chose someone who cares for and loves her.
The host ends by noting that most of this treatment comes from the religious mindset of the family, and says that the atheist side is convincing enough that few people challenge it. The segment then moves toward a commercial break, with a caller expected when the show returns.
Jesus, the Trinity, and God as a Deadbeat Father
Marlin, calling in from the Philippines, brought up the story of Jesus getting lost in the temple at age 12, which he compared to Home Alone. He said that Mary and Joseph spent three days looking for him and that God did nothing to intervene. The host said he had not known that was a Bible story, and Marlin said it was one of the joyful mysteries of the rosary.
The host explained that his point was more general. He was thinking of God as a deadbeat father. He asked Marlin whether he was a theist, and Marlin said he was a Filipino Roman Catholic. The host then asked whether he was a Trinitarian, meaning whether he believed in the Trinity.
The host said that if you are a Trinitarian, you believe that Jesus, God, and the Holy Spirit are all co-equal within the concept of God. In the New Testament, God became flesh, was born, did his ministry, and then died, indicating that he would come back to judge the wicked and bring the righteous up to heaven. For him, that is very close to the stereotypical deadbeat d
Trinity, Divine Fatherhood, and Harsh Old Testament Punishments
The host opens by questioning the Trinity as a comforting doctrine that falls apart under skeptical scrutiny. He argues that people don’t refer to themselves in the third person, so it makes little sense for God to speak of himself as Father and Son as if they were separate beings. He compares this to a title like Officer Greg or King Greg, noting that the same person would not address himself that way in his own internal monologue. If they share the same mind, they should share the same thoughts, so the verbal distinction is confusing at best.
The discussion turns to the traditional imagery of the Trinity, with God the Father as a bearded old man in the heavens and the Holy Spirit as a dove. The host notes that this is what he was taught in Sunday school, and that Protestants and Baptists generally accept the same Trinity. He points out that the Holy Spirit is described as the force that moves believers to do good works and serve the poor, though the Holy Spirit is depicted as a dove in the Gospel accounts. He concludes that the Trinity is not a biblical concept but something that evolved in the Catholic Church over several centuries, with Tertullian likely the first to discuss it around the third century.
The host then argues that the Trinity became doctrine largely because the Catholic Church set the example for later Christian groups. Even though the concept is absent from the Bible, it became part of the accepted mythology over time.
Turning to the Old Testament, the host questions how a loving, fatherly figure could be responsible for such harsh punishments. He cites the killing of the firstborn of Egypt and the Amalekites, including their infants and young boys, while the young girls were kept. He then recalls the story of Jephthah, who made a vow to sacrifice whatever first came out of his house, knowing it would be his daughter, and God did not stop the sacrifice as he did with Abraham. He observes that these are not isolated examples but a pattern of God acting in this way.
He also recounts that as a teenager he was persuaded by Mark Twain’s argument that God was a sadist. According to this argument, God placed the tree of knowledge in the garden knowing Adam and Eve would eat from it, and then punished them for doing so. The host stresses that this is Twain’s argument rather than his own, but says it was one of the things that convinced him. He ends by wondering how such a picture of God affects society as a whole.
Part 6
And then I don’t know, it’s, it’s spare the rod spoil the child. I mean, and I feel it’s even more insidious than that. Not only do they have to suffer that, but they are often given the mindset that you made me do this and I have to do this so that you will be a better person. when you have men who are raised in a Christian church for these ideals who think that you can be strict and physically abusive and Loving at the same time that it’s okay to like beat my children because I love them right, and I think Exactly Exactly, and I know I know one of the people who are in our
chat right now experience that growing up It was something I experienced growing up And so I it makes me really wonder how much how many children have to suffer? Because of this ideal that to be a father you have to be forceful and harsh like this all because God set that example for us So let’s combine the physical trauma with the emotional trauma of he’s beating me because it’s my fault. I did something wrong. And now that just leads to, well, now I deserve this sort of treatment. Mm -hmm, right? It’s just layer upon layer of, of, of bullshit, in my opinion. Yes. Yeah. And I’m sorry, I didn’t mean to bring anything up but
because I Yeah That’s one of the harder things too is the is like having to go through it all thinking that it was you that caused this To happen. I mean it is. I mean as somebody who’s been there it It’s hard. It’s really really hard No, it’s cool. You’re all good. Greg. You’re all good, man. It’s something I live with every day So, you know most of the time I’ve been living with CPTSD my whole life most of the time. I’m Yeah. And I, yeah. And we’re all the better for it. Yeah. And I will say this. I think you know, I think you know about my early part of my life where I
had a really hard time dealing with it And I was a homeless alcoholic drug addict I readily admit it, but I finally got it under control when I was in my mid 30s and I’m a little bit better now so I was able to live a fairly normal life and raise my own kids in a way that Wasn’t the same way I was raised. So, you know, you’ve got to learn to stop the Stop the cycle, right? Thank you. Thanks, Greg. I’m not really good at compliments I can, I cannot completely empathize with what you went through. I can sympathize to a certain extent because there was a, as there tends to be a kind
of a cycle of violence, especially in highly religious households, it is that expectation, the man is the father of the household as God is the father of everybody else, and he has to keep them in line. But I did want to say, and I’m not trying to glaze you here or thing but I think we’re all kind of, I am a better person for knowing you knowing what you’ve gone through knowing the things that happened to you but knowing the person that came out of that and I’m not justifying the former for the latter. But I think we’re all kind of better for knowing you, you, you comically ask sometimes why I keep you on
the show, because you are a example of what coming out of a religion what thinking for yourself, what examining things skeptically can lead you to so I’m, I’m not either I’m much better at giving them than I am at receiving them myself so yeah well they’re just they’re just echoing what I said so yeah well it’s It’s hard for me so yeah, my my birds do have a lot to say Yeah, there you go Hey, you know what and they’re really quiet. Usually it’s only in the morning that they’re like this believe it or not You know the rest of the day. They’re totally quiet It Showtime, I mean, you’re on camera they’re on camera
Part 7
But if you are, you’re not helping me. So just stay the fuck out of my way. Leave me alone. I’ll do it. If you want to jump in at some point, I’m happy to have the help, but just don’t work against me. Just get the hell out of my way and I’ll do shit myself. Right. And that’s kind of what I what I went with. And that was one of the things that helped me. Because, again, as you said, you have to realize that there is not going to be any God out there to help you do things. Everything that happens that you attributed to that God was just you giving the credit to somebody
else instead of assuming the credit for yourself. So very much with you there on your sentiment. You know, my wife, she was a radiation therapist for a while and they had clients who, you know, they got to ring the bell, you know, at the end when they were they were done with their treatment. And and they would they would a lot of them would thank the therapist. They would thank, you know, the doctors, the therapists and everything like that. And that was fine. But there was a subset who would not thank the therapist, would not thank the doctors, but would thank God. And it was just, you know, it was so frustrating. All the stuff
that she had to go through, all the stuff that she had to learn, the years that she spent, she’s put herself in all this debt just to help other people. And then for the people who she helps to just thank someone else is insane. You know, right. Right. Right. I’m trying to think of the word but I can’t think of it Um, it’s disgusting to me in a way that people don’t give credit to The medical profession when they you know when they do things like this. Yeah, and you see it all the time It’s not just with with uh, this This, you know particular thing here So I I see it all the time
when people go. Oh, I got better from my cancer Oh, I I survived this god did it. Yeah, but You know, I had a friend that had a he had a weird abscess on his leg that wouldn’t heal And he started and he started seeing a new doctor But at the same time he went to a new church and at the new church they started actively praying over his body and his uh, his abscess ended up getting better he’d had it for Over a year and it ended up getting better and he attributed it to the people praying over him and not the new doctor Right. It just doesn’t make any sense to me at
all Yeah. If he wouldn’t have gotten the help that he needed, he wouldn’t have been better. Oh, my gosh. Oh, my gosh. Yeah. I had a I had another friend uh back years and years and years ago. Um, I was living in a different state and his mother had uh mental Problems and she started going to a new church and they convinced her that the medications that the doctors were giving her Were causing the medical problems And she ended up taking she ended up not taking them. She ended up having to be uh Locked up and eventually later took her own life which you know And this was all because of these religious fanatics telling
her that she didn’t need This medication that god was going to make her better, right? I that’s so sad. And I have I have a similar story. A person I knew this was back before I met her. But she she has bipolar disorder pretty bad. And her grandmother was watching her one day and had the bipolar medication. And she was like, what is this? And, you know, she said, my friend said, well, you know, it’s it’s for my mother. My bipolar, you know, if I don’t take it, then I’ll I’ll have really bad mood swings. And she said, no, you don’t need this. You need you need the Lord. And she flushed him down the
Part 8
So, yeah, the premise basically is I want to I want to have people who have actual experience and activating people or getting people politically engaged as a co host. And then I want to talk about Christian nationalism, how to fight against it. Cool Maybe throw some minor news about the politics affecting atheists using the dam shows heat map of bills. Shameless shill. The dam show has a map. I don’t know if we can bring it up. Sorry to put Chris on the spot there for a second. Um, I you know, well, it’s over on the uh, the damn show at the damn show .com. So you can find it there I I’m sure I could
he’s not in seat right now too And i’m sure that I could bring it on if I knew where to find that but uh I but I don’t write off the bat Gotcha. It’s called if you go to the dam show dot com slash theocracy dash watch dash map or just go to the dam show dot com and up at the top, click theocracy map. There’s a legislation tracker, which shows laws about church and schools, reproductive bands, LGBTQ restrictions and books and exemptions. And it’s a really good map, really good tool. I can’t stress it enough. If you are in the United States, take a look at this map, see what’s going on in your
area and get involved locally because that’s where you can make the biggest impact. But yeah, that’s basically how I want to do the show. I want to get people activated. I want to get people out there and actually involved in their communities. And so we can make a better a better place because like I said before, no one’s going to save us. We’ve got a we’ve got to do this ourselves. Yep Well said. Oh, yeah. Yeah, well, yeah very well said Have you ever done any political activism jack? I have to ask you Yeah, okay, cool I had to ask I have a I’m involved in a local group in my area. We go to
the county commission. We go. I’ve done some statewide stuff too. You know, I’ve done everything from the federal level to the local level and everything in between. Just I’ve most of the stuff that I do those local Hmm that’s totally true and and you know, who was it that said all politics are local, right? just because I have a better impact on that. And it doesn’t come up as much. The state stuff and the federal stuff doesn’t move as quickly as the local stuff. You’ll find out if you’re if you’re doing this. I mean it starts everything starts in your community Yeah, right. And I I always get on people’s cases that don’t vote in
their local elections And you know the person who’s in charge of your town Has a much bigger impact on your day -to -day life than the united states president does Voting for the for the city council is way more important than voting for the president and people don’t do it It’s it’s amazing to me Yeah, I mean, I know who my county officials are. I know who is my district county commissioner. I know who my city district, you know, leader is I and I don’t know pretty much anybody who else knows outside of my group. So if you can know that at least and see what’s going on, you know, usually county commission meets once
a week. Mine meets once or twice a month. But yeah, like if you can know that and just know what’s going on in your area, you’ll be so much more informed about upcoming events and stuff and you’ll actually make a stronger community. And get involved Because, right, get involved. Absolutely. Right. And even if you’re not willing to be a part of or have the time commitment to be a part of these, then what you can do is just show up and talk or you can email them. I’m sure there are some committees in your town some some committees that need help Right. I’m sure there are and but Like like parks and recreation has a
Cannabis legalization, hemp restrictions, and lobbying
Coming from California, where cannabis was already legal, to Texas, where it was demonized, is a striking change. For no good reason that I can think of. It’s encouraging, though. I wish I could say the same for Tennessee. There was a poll a couple of years ago showing that 70 percent of Tennesseans would like to see legalization, and every year it just gets worse.
Governor Bill Lee recently patched a loophole that allowed people to sell THC-9, I believe it is, instead of regular THC. Then the restriction was handed off to the food and beverage side, so you can’t sell flour or anything like that, even from hemp plants. It cripples the hemp industry, which is something Tennessee has strived to do for a long time. I don’t understand why people keep doubling down. The people in Texas even made stricter laws last year.
There are some big businesses, especially in the southeast part of the state near northeast or northwest Georgia, because that’s where the big carpet industry is. From what I understand, these decisions are lobbied for by the alcohol industry, at least here. That really surprised me with the current trends in the country. In the last decade, it seemed like cannabis was more of an issue for drawing voters out to support more liberal candidates. I would think that if you can get voters to come out and vote for you because you’re pro-legalization, why wouldn’t you be pro-legalization if you wanted to get elected?
We just saw this in Texas last year, when the state’s attorney said that if you want legalization, you’re going to have to vote me out. And they did. Yep. There you go. Ask and you receive, or something like that. He literally said it, and it might not have been the exact quote, but it was very close: if you want legalization, you’re going to have to vote me out.
There’s another factor in Tennessee. We have the headquarters for CoreCivic. I don’t know if you’ve heard of CoreCivic, but they’re the for-profit prison company. A lot of them, and GEO Group is one of those, are running what some people call concentration camps.

Leave a Reply