This episode examines religious relics and the claims built around them, from the supposed Noah’s Ark site in Turkey to the Shroud of Turin and pieces of Jesus’s cross. Chris, his guests and a caller test the evidence and discuss why people still want physical objects to anchor their faith.
Is the Noah’s Ark site in Turkey real?
Chris and his guests say the formation is a natural feature, not a boat. They describe Ron Wyatt as misleading people about iron fittings, saying the soil is naturally iron rich, so a metal detector held near the ground always registers. They claim he skimmed above the surface and lowered the detector at grid points to create a pattern. Ground penetrating radar, they add, shows only natural cavities. A viewer, Kelly Laughlin, is credited with noting that iron degrades quickly in saltwater, and a speaker says ancient ships used wood or copper fittings. One guest notes the site has been pinned to the same place since the 1950s.
Is the Shroud of Turin real or a forgery?
One speaker calls the Shroud one of history’s biggest forgeries. The speaker cites a letter from Bishop Pierre d’Arcis to the Pope saying his predecessor commissioned the cloth as artwork to draw pilgrims, and that he knew the artist. Radiocarbon dating places it in the 13th century, and the techniques used to recreate it were available then. Another guest notes the Bible describes burial cloths as strips, not one long sheet. The group also describes an experiment where a man painted himself blue and lay on cloth, producing a wide, distorted and unconvincing image.
Could pieces of Jesus’s cross have survived?
Chris asks caller Marlin how anyone could tell a piece of wood came from Jesus’s cross and not the thief’s, and Marlin cannot answer. Chris notes the Bible says only that the crucifixion happened at Golgotha, outside the city. He argues the upright beam would have stayed standing, Roman crosses were costly and likely reused, and nobody would have saved the cross before the resurrection. He adds the cross became a Christian symbol only after Constantine, and asks why nobody cared for about three hundred years, comparing it to keeping Marie Antoinette’s guillotine.
Are religious relics a form of idolatry?
Adrian Belgrave says he sees relics as a path toward idolatry. Chris agrees that the object can come to matter more than the observance, and acknowledges that people want a connection to what they love, as with the prop AT-ST on his desk. The line, the hosts say, is relying on an object for answered prayer. Chris warns that people can be sold anything when emotions are high, from vials of hair to a Kennedy bullet on eBay. Relics, he says, are evidence of what people believed, not proof that those beliefs are true.
Transcript highlights
Selected passages from the live stream, lightly edited for readability. Click a section time to jump to that part of the video.
Relics, Ark Claims, and Stream Logistics
The hosts open by discussing Church relics, the supposed Noah’s Ark site studied since the 1950s and repeatedly ruled out, the chariot wheels said to lie at the bottom of the Red Sea, and the relic claims that have been stolen or are said to be invisible. Mentioning the invisible engagement ring of Catherine of Siena, one host notes that it is said to be a ring made from the foreskin of Jesus Christ, one that nobody can see, feel, or find, but which supposedly is there.
One host points out that Catherine was a nun, so she was considered a bride of Christ rather than someone engaged to him. The conversation then turns to the stream’s commercial vote, with viewers choosing between Pharaoh’s Curse, Wild Bill, and a foreskin restoration kit. Because the vote ended in a three-way tie, the hosts agree to settle it by picking among the options, and the foreskin restoration kit is chosen.
The hosts also talk about the stream’s new phone line for callers and a web page for calling in. One host explains that the call-in system is partly automated and that the team is running it in the background to help the hosts avoid problems, referring to a rough call-in session the night before. The hosts add that the commercial vote resets after each commercial, so viewers can vote for the next one about thirty minutes later.
Noah’s Ark, Ark claims and the Shroud of Turin
Chris and his guests start with Noah’s Ark and the Ark site in Turkey. One of them says the formation is clearly a natural feature and not a boat, comparing the “it looks like skin” reasoning to a looks-like-therefore-is argument. The discussion turns to Ron Wyatt, who is described as having misled people about iron fittings at the site. According to the speaker, the soil there is naturally iron rich, so a metal detector held close to the ground will always register a hit, and Wyatt would skim above the surface where there were no hits and then lower the detector at grid points to create a pattern of supposed fittings. The speaker says a video of this exists and that the ground penetrating radar claims are equally unreliable, showing only natural cavities.
The group also questions the site itself. One guest says the Ark has been pinned to the same location since the 1950s, and asks whether it is the wrong mountain. Another speaker says the Bible refers to the “mountains of Ararat” in the plural, which suggests the vague location was deliberately left open. A viewer named Kelly Laughlin is credited in the chat with pointing out that iron degrades very rapidly in saltwater, so iron fittings from a flood-era vessel would not have survived. The speaker adds that ancient ships used wood or copper fittings because copper holds up better in seawater.
On the question of how the Ark could hold every animal, the discussion moves to the ambiguity of the measurements. One guest explains that a cubit was not a standard unit but roughly the distance from fingertip to elbow, which varied by whoever was doing the carpentry. Another guest recalls asking their parents as a child and being told that the animals might have been shrunk, or that only their DNA was carried and recreated afterward. A third joke about Pokeball technology gets a laugh, and the group jokes about gopher wood as well.
The conversation then shifts to the Shroud of Turin. One speaker calls it one of history’s biggest forgeries and says it is astonishing that people still accept it. The speaker cites a letter from Bishop Pierre d’Arcis to the Pope, which says his predecessor commissioned the cloth as an artwork to draw pilgrims, and says he knew which artist made it. The speaker adds that radiocarbon dating places the cloth in the 13th century and that the techniques used to recreate it were available at that time. Another guest notes that the Bible describes burial cloths as strips, so a single long cloth folded over would not match the biblical description.
Finally, the group discusses a recent experiment in which a man painted himself blue and lay on a strip of cloth to test the image transfer. The speakers say the result was a wide, distorted and unconvincing image, which they present as the clearest demonstration that the Shroud could not have formed that way. The section ends with a joke that Jesus might have visited America and left the Shroud there, before someone quips that it must have been brought back to Italy by Columbus.
Doubting Relics of the Cross and Mormon Claims
Chris opens by mocking the idea that Columbus’s discovery proves Jesus visited the Americas, and calls the Book of Mormon’s prophet Joseph Smith a convicted con man whose multiple wives, some of them children, do not raise doubts among believers. He then says he would love to hear a theist explain why the relics, such as pieces of the cross, are real. He invites callers to phone in and make that case.
The conversation turns to Marlin, a regular caller from the Philippines, who has been invited on to talk about relics such as the Ark of the Covenant, Noah’s Ark and the Shroud of Turin. Marlin says he has heard that there are pieces of the cross in Jerusalem and in Rome, and he offers to search for how they were verified. Chris presses him on the key question: how could anyone tell that a piece of wood came from Jesus’s cross and not from the cross of the thief beside him? Marlin cannot answer, and Chris points out that the Bible says only that Jesus was crucified at Golgotha, outside the city, and never identifies a precise location.
Chris then works through the logistics of crucifixion. He argues that the cross was probably not carefully preserved after Jesus was removed, since the body would have been pulled down roughly and the upright beam would still have been standing. Roman crosses were large and costly to build, so the timber would likely have been reused on the next condemned man. He adds that some Roman executions used a fixed upright post with a crossbeam that could be lifted and reused again and again. In his view, nobody would have saved the cross before the resurrection, because at that point no one knew it would become important.
Chris also addresses the picture Bibles that show men using ladders to take Jesus down. He acknowledges that the Catholic wooden statues depicting the descent from the cross may reflect symbolism, but he insists that even with ladders, the upright cross would have remained in the ground. He concludes that if the cross was still standing, it would most likely have been used again. He notes that the cross only became a Christian symbol after Constantine began converting Rome to Christianity, which he presents as a further reason to doubt that the original cross was preserved.
Constantine, the Cross, and the Problem of Relics
The discussion starts with the story of Constantine, who supposedly saw a cross of stars in the sky before a battle and then converted the empire. The host points out that the fish symbol came first, and that it worked as a secret sign for persecuted Christians who would draw half of it in the sand to identify one another. He argues that the victory was more likely coincidence than divine intervention. He suggests that Constantine’s conversion may have been driven by a practical concern: his mother was a vocal Christian, and he did not want to have to execute her.
The host then turns to the Holy Land sites, saying that Constantine’s mother picked locations like the Church of the Holy Sepulchre based on how the places felt to her. He questions why nobody seemed to care about the cross for roughly three hundred years after the crucifixion, then suddenly treated it as sacred. He compares this to keeping Marie Antoinette’s guillotine for centuries without mentioning it to anyone. He asks why anyone would preserve the instrument that killed a man they believed was dead, since the apostles did not expect a resurrection until it happened.
Addressing a claim about Peter being crucified upside down, the host says there is no evidence for it, and that even if it happened, it would only show what Peter believed, not whether Jesus was God. He notes that the Gospels are anonymous and that the cross was not treated as special until after Constantine began changing the empire. He adds that the early relic trade likely existed, but that solid evidence for it only appears later.
A viewer, Adrian, joins and argues that God’s hidden nature is part of a mysterious plan. The host responds that a divinely hidden God is indistinguishable from no God at all, and that a deity who chooses to stay concealed for no reason would be cruel rather than mysterious. He says that if he were God, he would not remain hidden. The host also says that asking people to have faith and stop thinking about these questions is asking them to turn off their brains, which he refuses to do.
The conversation then moves to the show’s voting games for the next commercial, where chat votes for a post-mortem baptismal soul sword and the foreskin of baby Jesus. The host jokes that the foreskin is the more appropriate relic to discuss given the topic.
Relics, Idolatry and Religious Objects
Adrian Belgrave joins the show after a commercial break, and the conversation turns to relics. Adrian says he tends to see them as a path toward idolatry, and that he does not want them around him for that reason. He notes that his own theological lane differs from Catholic and Orthodox practice, so he is careful about speaking for those traditions.
Chris agrees that relics can lead straight into idolatry, because the object can end up mattering more than the religious observance it is meant to support. He points to the Jerusalem temple, which he says was regarded as the seat of God, so defiling it was seen as disrespect toward God himself. In his view, the temple and the things kept within it became the idols people fixed on, and the Catholic Church in its early years seems to have taken a similar path while knowing it should not.
Chris also acknowledges why relics appeal to people. Everybody wants a connection to what matters most to them, and a physical object can make that connection feel more real. He offers his own example of memorabilia, a prop AT-ST from Star Wars on his desk, which he keeps because it represents something he loves and helps him connect with it. He draws a clear line, though, between that kind of personal keepsake and the religious devotion that gives a relic its power.
Part 6
like his, like Luke’s actual lightsaber handle from Star Wars, hundreds of thousand dollars because people really value that because it gives them a direct connection back to that thing that they love. I think that’s what relics are for us. They’re a psychological connection back to a thing that’s important, but that doesn’t give the, that doesn’t mean that they’re real and that they’re actually like that lightsaber hilts. Not just going to, you know, if I don’t get a hold of that thing someday, I’m not going to flip the switch and have it actually turn on and be a lightsaber as much as I really want that to happen. It’s not going to cause it’s not a
real lightsaber, just so unfortunate that. My flying spaghetti monster is not going to bless me with his noodley goodness no matter how much I wish he would have. Right. That right there, that relic, that’s a relic. my mindset myself like like i’m just like your star wars thing or erin’s spaghetti noodle thing like i think there’s a difference between or even face the point like my freaking superman action figures that i got in my dragon ball pop figures that i got inside my room like i consider those just figures but it’s not something that i worship and say like oh you know come and help me out with my struggle here um super saiyan god
go to action figure up in here you know i’m saying i’m not looking up to them and saying hey you know as a as an object of worship i think that’s the big difference oh yeah i agree i agree yeah i agree like that’s that’s it’s a fine line between like No, that that is a difference. And that is where it gets where it gets into dangerous territory with people being able to take advantage of the idea of relics to manipulate people. And I think, you know, I think that it also kind of depends on your your definition of worship, too. I mean, you you and I both know that in the Bible, it talks
about idolatry, about just being, you know, and and so even if they don’t have like necessarily a spiritual context, there can be an element of worship if they mean enough to you, at least at least in a biblical in a biblical sort of definition of worship after after Princess Diana’s. possessing those things and like just for like collection type purposes or whatever and then relying on them for you know for you to for answered prayer for example or relying on them to help you throughout life you know i mean i think that’s the fine line difference there People can be sold anything, especially when their emotions are high. You can be convinced that something’s real,
people will buy it. If they want to have a connection to something, it becomes incredibly important that they possess it, that they have it, that they keep it. I said when we were talking to Marlin, I think that pretty much immediately after the crucifixion, some people who believed in Jesus could have been sold pieces of wood that were just random pieces of driftwood and told that they were pieces of that cross and they would have bought it because they wanted to have that connection. that’s a good example right there that’s a great example After she died, people were selling vials of blonde hair, claiming it was her and people freaking bought them. It was insane.
You can find the magic bullet that killed Kennedy on eBay today. You could probably search and find one. Things that you could probably find a little, a piece of Trump’s ear from 2023, that you could probably find somebody selling that piece. Or the maxi pad that he wore over it. Because somebody will buy it, somebody will believe it, believe it’s real, and buy it, yeah i’ll tell you that and i think that’s a real danger that’s why i stay away from and then they’ll pass it down saying that it’s real, that it’s real, it’s real, it’s real, and over time, a lot of times, it becomes seen as like, oh, this is true because of
Relics, Human Attachment, and Confirmation Bias
The relics show us what those people in that area were thinking at the time, even if it wasn’t real. That’s fascinating for this society. Do you think people will see relics as less important as time goes on, or will they still look back on them and try to decipher what their mindset was back then, how they were living? Let’s say 50 years from now, will people still look at relics the same way we do now?
I think people are definitely going to continue wanting a physical connection back to things. Relics can serve as evidence of beliefs for some people. They look at it and it becomes really important because it shows that, yes, this is real, this is a physical thing that proves my beliefs are real. When people don’t look deeper and don’t ask the questions, they run into the problem of using those as confirmation, and that becomes confirmation bias. But we’re always going to have a desire to find those things. That’s why archaeology is still a thing.
In archaeology, relics are studied as evidence rather than as faith. We don’t pick up a piece of pottery and say it must have belonged to a guy named Wilson who lived here 150,000 years ago. That is sometimes what they do with religious relics. We look at an object and ask what it is, then observe it, test it, and figure it out. That still gives us a connection back to the past, back to another point in time, and that is important. Religious relics are evidence of what people believed at a time, but not evidence that their beliefs are true.
They’re still creating new relics even today, especially in the Catholic religion. There are pieces of the Pope’s things, crosses, or rosaries that the Pope himself blessed, holy water blessed by the Pope, and toast with Jesus’s face on it. New relics are being created every day. I would see that as a personal relic. We’ll see which ones last the test of time and are still venerated in 50 years. But the human instinct to want physical items to confirm, justify, and affirm faith is not going anywhere. That’s human nature. We want to be connected to the things that are important to us, and that will never go away as long as we have brains.
I wear a necklace my kids gave me, a little anatomical heart. I always wear it because they gave it to me. That’s a relic to me only. My wedding ring is another one. I don’t wear it right now because my finger has shrunk so much since I got married that it falls off, and getting rings resized is expensive. I’ve lost so much weight that you definitely want to wait until you’re done changing sizes before you resize anything. My original ring doesn’t fit anymore, and I miss the ring I got, but it’s too small now.
Coffee, rationalization, and upcoming show schedule
The best part of church for me was the coffee hour, but I grew up LDS, so we didn’t drink coffee and there was no coffee hour. We had three hours of church and then you went home and ate. That makes me really glad I didn’t join a church, if the best part of it was coffee hour, because I don’t drink coffee at all. I find it bitter and I don’t like it. I prefer to get my caffeine the old-fashioned way, from carbonated beverages. I’m a Mountain Dew girl myself.
The Mormon faith did say at one point that they don’t drink coffee and tea because of the caffeine, but they haven’t actually banned caffeinated sodas, though some people do avoid them. Most Mormon women I know are addicted to caffeine. They have this caffeinated hot chocolate and they say it’s not coffee because it’s hot chocolate. Even in the wording of the Word of Wisdom, it says hot drinks, which was then interpreted to mean coffee and tea, but not hot chocolate. It’s just so silly. Hot chocolate is a dessert, not a drink.
You find any way to rationalize the things you want to keep doing. It’s funny because the Mormons aren’t the only ones who do it. We always find ways of rationalizing these things. I personally am a great rationalizer.
I think it’s one of those human nature things. There are different portions of our brain that process our evaluations of our own actions versus the actions of other people. When we’re evaluating what someone else is doing, one part of our brain is active. When we’re evaluating what we’re doing, a different part is active.
This is really important in morals, because we can look at what somebody else is doing and say that’s wrong, but we can do the exact same th

Leave a Reply